Beneath the Veneer of Calm
Vasily Astrov, Alexandra Bykova, Rumen Dobrinsky, Selena Duraković, Meryem Gökten, Richard Grieveson, Doris Hanzl-Weiss, Marcus How, Gabor Hunya, Branimir Jovanović, Niko Korpar, Sebastian Leitner, Isilda Mara, Olga Pindyuk, Sandor Richter, Bernd Christoph Ströhm, Maryna Tverdostup, Zuzana Zavarská and Adam Żurawski
wiiw Forecast Report No. Autumn 2023, October 2023
156 pages including 30 Tables and 52 Figures
The current report is only available to members. Past issues become freely available online when the next report is released. Several individual sections of the report are freely available to download now (see below).
Executive summary
by Branimir Jovanović
free download
Indicators 2021-2022 and Outlook 2023-2025
Premium Members only
Summary of key recent macroeconomic data for CESEE, and overview of new wiiw forecasts for 2023-2025 (Excel file)
1. Global overview: German and Chinese weakness weighing on CESEE outlook
by Richard Grieveson
The war in Ukraine is likely going to last for much or all of our forecast period. However, the direct economic fallout from the war for most of CESEE will be limited. The outlook for Germany in particular and for the euro area economy has deteriorated, and next year’s recovery will be weaker than we had previously expected. Inflation has peaked in the euro area and will trend downward. The ECB has finished its tightening cycle and will start to cut next year. The global economy is mixed, with China struggling, while the US remains impressively resilient to monetary tightening and external headwinds. For CESEE, the combined negative impact of weakness in the euro area and China is a major headwind for growth.
2. Political risks in CESEE 2024-2024: Strategic outlook
by Marcus How
Over 18 months on from the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, its fallout continues to be the key driver of political risks in CESEE. Security aside, the cost to CESEE states of severing their various economic ties with Russia is proving high – especially for those that are EU members. The Russian and Ukrainian governments remain uncompromising on the possibility of a peace settlement. Military strategies remain attritional, as each of the two sides seeks to degrade the weaponry, logistics,
infrastructure and morale of the other. The Ukrainian counteroffensive continues but is grinding along only slowly. Political instability in the US represents a major risk to the Ukrainian war effort, while elections in Slovakia, Poland and Austria may lead the EU consensus surrounding sanctions and aid to begin to unravel. At the same time, the US and the EU have taken major steps to ensure that Ukraine continues to receive military support in the long term; this will sustain its defences, even if it cannot deliver victory.
free download
3. CESEE overview: Beneath the Veneer of Calm
by Branimir Jovanović
The economy of the CESEE region continues to outperform the EU average, but there are notable differences between the various sub-regions. The EU-CEE countries performed worse than expected, due to the recession in Germany. The Western Balkan countries performed better than expected, thanks to tourism, remittances and FDI. And the CIS countries and Ukraine also did better than anticipated, as they adapted to the new reality. Inflation is proving far more persistent than previously imagined; it is driven not just by global energy prices, but also by company profits, price rises in other sectors and, most recently, higher wages. The price increases are having a serious adverse effect on people’s living standards and poverty, and some indicators have worsened dramatically. Growth in 2024 and 2025 will be lower than previously expected, on account of the global
slowdown, the weak EU economy, the more persistent inflation, the tighter monetary conditions and less-supportive fiscal policy. Inflation will also be higher and will not return to 2% any time soon, as its dynamics have become far more complex and are no longer driven just by higher global energy.
4. Austria and CESEE: Trade affected by a two-speed EU-CEE
by Doris Hanzl-Weiss
The outlook for many of Austria’s key trading partners in CESEE has deteriorated since our last forecast. However, despite downward revisions in our forecasts, several of Austria’s main trading partners in the group of Central and East European EU members (EU-CEE) – in particular, Slovenia, Croatia and Romania – continue to perform relatively well, and thus still offer some growth impetus for Austria this year. The region will recover in the next two years, but by less than expected. Next year, the countries of Southeast Europe will again be the top performers; but in 2025 Poland will be the star.
5. Convergence Monitor: CESEE again proves its resilience
by Richard Grieveson
The years since 2019 have been tumultuous ones for CESEE, with the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020, followed by Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. In this context, over this period the continued per capita GDP convergence of almost all the CESEE countries with Germany has been remarkable. 21 of the 23 CESEE countries posted per capita GDP convergence with Germany in purchasing power standard (PPS) terms. The top performers were Turkey, Romania, Poland and Croatia, all of which increased their wealth levels versus Germany by 7 percentage points or more. However, while the positive per capita convergence performance is a welcome sign, it may have been helped by the region’s loss of population. Our new forecasts suggest that most countries of the region will continue to catch up with Germany, but there are major challenges to future convergence performance.
free download
No. | Title | Author | |
---|---|---|---|
1 | ALBANIA: Economic growth supported by external demand | Isilda Mara | |
2 | BELARUS: Recovery gathering pace, but the future remains uncertain | Rumen Dobrinsky | |
3 | BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA: Economy stagnating, as political tensions come to the fore | Selena Duraković | |
4 | BULGARIA: Economic weakness likely to persist | Rumen Dobrinsky | |
5 | CROATIA: Tourism to keep economy afloat | Bernd Christoph Ströhm | |
6 | CZECHIA: In the slow lane | Zuzana Zavarská | |
7 | ESTONIA: No swift economic recovery on the cards | Maryna Tverdostup | |
8 | HUNGARY: A bumpy road to recovery from the recession | Sandor Richter | |
9 | KAZAKHSTAN: Robust economic growth weakens slightly | Alexandra Bykova | |
10 | KOSOVO: Renewed tensions with Serbia jeopardising economic prospects | Isilda Mara | |
11 | LATVIA: Waiting for the tide to float the boats | Sebastian Leitner | |
12 | LITHUANIA: Stagnation to last longer than expected | Sebastian Leitner | |
13 | MOLDOVA: Emerging from depression | Gabor Hunya | |
14 | MONTENEGRO: Election results could offer fresh hope | Bernd Christoph Ströhm | |
15 | NORTH MACEDONIA: Same Old Story | Branimir Jovanović | |
16 | POLAND: Technically in recession | Adam Żurawski | |
17 | ROMANIA: How much fiscal consolidation? | Gabor Hunya | |
18 | RUSSIA: Resisting depreciation pressures | Vasily Astrov | |
19 | SERBIA: A lighter shade of grey | Branimir Jovanović | |
20 | SLOVAKIA: Automotive industry propping up growth, but for how long? | Doris Hanzl-Weiss | |
21 | SLOVENIA: Worst flooding in decades is the defining moment of the year | Niko Korpar | |
22 | TURKEY: A balancing act between growth and disinflation | Meryem Gökten | |
23 | UKRAINE: Economy showing resilience in wartime | Olga Pindyuk |
The economy of the CESEE region continues to outperform the EU average, but there are notable differences between the various sub-regions. The EU-CEE countries performed worse than expected, due to the recession in Germany, while the Western Balkan countries performed better than expected, thanks to tourism, remittances and FDI. And the CIS countries and Ukraine also did better than anticipated, as they adapted to the new reality. Inflation is proving far more persistent than previously imagined; it is driven not just by global energy prices, but also by company profits, price rises in other sectors and, most recently, higher wages. The price increases are having a serious adverse effect on people’s living standards and poverty, and some indicators have worsened dramatically. Growth in 2024 and 2025 will be lower than previously expected, on account of the global slowdown, the weak EU economy, the more persistent inflation, the tighter monetary conditions and less-supportive fiscal policy. Inflation will also be higher and will not return to 2% any time soon, as its dynamics have become far more complex and are no longer driven just by higher global energy.
Reference to wiiw databases: wiiw Annual Database, wiiw Monthly Database, wiiw FDI Database
Keywords: CESEE, Central and Eastern Europe, economic forecast, Western Balkans, Visegrád group, CIS, Ukraine, Russia, Turkey, euro area, EU, convergence, Russia-Ukraine war, Russia sanctions, commodity prices, inflation, energy crisis, gas, renewable energy, electricity, monetary and fiscal policy, EU funds, purchasing power, poverty, real wages, remittances, FDI, imports, external debt, interest rates, banking sector, credit, impact on Austria, macroeconomic forecasting
JEL classification: E20, E21, E22, E24, E32, E5, E62, F21, F31, H60, I18, J20, J30, O47, O52, O57, P24, P27, P33, P52
Countries covered: Albania, Austria, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Central and East Europe, CESEE, CIS, Croatia, Czechia, Estonia, Euro Area, European Union, Hungary, Kazakhstan, Kosovo, Latvia, Lithuania, Moldova, Montenegro, North Macedonia, Poland, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Southeast Europe, Turkey, Ukraine, US, Western Balkans
Research Areas: Macroeconomic Analysis and Policy, International Trade, Competitiveness and FDI
ISBN-13: 978-3-85209-078-8
Press Releases
Related Presentations
- Unter dem Deckmantel der Gelassenheit (press conference presentation in German)
- Beneath the Veneer of Calm (webinar presentation in English)